17 Oct 2026
New York Red Bulls
0 – 2
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer ✗
14 Mar 2026
Toronto FC
1 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
25 Jun 2025
Toronto FC
1 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
22 Mar 2025
New York Red Bulls
2 – 1
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
02 Oct 2024
Toronto FC
1 – 4
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
28 Jul 2024
New York Red Bulls
0 – 0
Toronto FC
Leagues Cup
22 Jun 2024
New York Red Bulls
3 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
07 Oct 2023
New York Red Bulls
3 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
17 May 2023
Toronto FC
0 – 0
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
18 Jun 2022
New York Red Bulls
2 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
05 Mar 2022
Toronto FC
1 – 4
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
21 Jul 2021
Toronto FC
1 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
08 May 2021
New York Red Bulls
2 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
08 Nov 2020
New York Red Bulls
2 – 1
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
14 Oct 2020
Toronto FC
1 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
03 Aug 2019
New York Red Bulls
2 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
18 Jul 2019
Toronto FC
3 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
22 Sep 2018
New York Red Bulls
2 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
01 Jul 2018
Toronto FC
0 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
05 Nov 2017
Toronto FC
0 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
30 Oct 2017
New York Red Bulls
1 – 2
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
30 Sep 2017
Toronto FC
4 – 2
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
19 May 2017
New York Red Bulls
1 – 1
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
18 Sep 2016
Toronto FC
3 – 3
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
28 May 2016
New York Red Bulls
3 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
06 Mar 2016
New York Red Bulls
0 – 2
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
14 Oct 2015
Toronto FC
2 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
15 Aug 2015
New York Red Bulls
3 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
11 Oct 2014
New York Red Bulls
3 – 1
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
28 Jun 2014
New York Red Bulls
2 – 2
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
17 May 2014
Toronto FC
2 – 0
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
14 Sep 2013
New York Red Bulls
2 – 0
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
20 Jul 2013
Toronto FC
0 – 0
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
27 Apr 2013
Toronto FC
1 – 2
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
29 Sep 2012
New York Red Bulls
4 – 1
Toronto FC
Major League Soccer
30 Jun 2012
Toronto FC
1 – 1
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer