Columbus Crew vs New York City FC Prediction

US Open Cup · Thu 21 May 2026
USA flag USA : US Open Cup
Columbus CrewDWWWW
1 - 0
Full time · HT 0 - 0
Kick-offThu 21 May, 00:30
Our tip1 @ 1.88 ✓
GoalsOver 2.5
Confidence70%

Full-time report

Our tip1 ✓
Double chance1X ✓
BTTSYes ✗
Over/Under 2.5Over 2.5 ✗

Recent form

Last 5 matches, home and away
Columbus CrewDWWWW
07 Nov 26AChicago Fire4 - 3Major League Soccer
31 Oct 26HDC United3 - 0Major League Soccer
29 Oct 26AFC Dallas2 - 0Major League Soccer
24 Oct 26HToronto FC4 - 2Major League Soccer
22 Oct 26HSt. Louis City0 - 0US Open Cup
New York City FC

No matches found.

Head to head

Full head to head: Columbus Crew vs New York City FC →

Our prediction

Columbus Crew to win

@ 1.88
Double chance
1X  •  Columbus Crew or Draw
@ 1.22
Both teams to score
Yes – both teams score
@ 1.55
Confidence
70%

Our record

Our tips on Columbus Crewlast 20 tipped matches
12/2060%

Correct 1X2 tips (home win, draw or away win), checked against the final score.

Who will win?

Voting closed at kick-off.

Goals outlook

Over/Under 2.5
Over 2.5
Confidence
95%
Over 2.5: 85%Under 2.5: 15%
Expected goals
2.23Columbus Crew
4.75Total
2.52New York City FC

Possible correct scores

1 – 1 Draw 10% @ 6.50
2 – 1 Columbus Crew win 9% @ 7.00 Our pick
1 – 0 Columbus Crew win 8% @ 7.50 ✓ Final score
2 – 0 Columbus Crew win 7% @ 9.00
0 – 0 Draw 7% @ 9.50

Final score: 1 – 0 – in our list ✓. Exact scores are long shots – even the likeliest score usually comes in only 1 time in 8–10. 18+.

Win probability

Columbus Crew61%
Draw20%
New York City FC19%

Odds (1X2)

11.88
X3.65
23.55

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC preview and result

Columbus Crew and New York City FC met in the US Open Cup on Thursday 21 May 2026 at 00:30 (Nigerian time). The match finished 1 - 0, 0 - 0 at half time.

Our model gives Columbus Crew a 61% chance of winning, the draw 20% and New York City FC 19%. Our pick was Columbus Crew to win with 70% confidence at odds of 1.88. The pick came in ✓. For a safer option, the double chance 1X (Columbus Crew or Draw) covers two of the three results at odds of 1.22.

Goals: we expect about 4.8 goals (2.2 for Columbus Crew, 2.5 for New York City FC). The chance of three or more goals is 85%, so our goals pick is Over 2.5 (95% confidence). 1 goal was scored.

Form and head to head

Columbus Crew have 4 wins, 1 draw and 0 defeats in their last 5 matches (D-W-W-W-W), scoring 13 and conceding 5.

Frequently asked questions

What was the prediction for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Our pre-match prediction is Columbus Crew to win (70% confidence) at odds of 1.88. Win chances: Columbus Crew 61%, draw 20%, New York City FC 19%.

Will there be over 2.5 goals in Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

We expect about 4.8 goals. Our pick is Over 2.5 with 95% confidence (chance of 3+ goals: 85%).

What time is Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC (US Open Cup) was played on Thursday 21 May 2026 at 00:30 Nigerian time (WAT).

What is a safe bet for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

The double chance 1X (Columbus Crew or Draw) covers two outcomes at odds of 1.22. No bet is risk-free – stake only what you can afford. 18+.

Predictions are estimates from our model, not guarantees. 18+ only – bet responsibly. More: today's predictions · Bet Slip Builder · booking codes.