New York City FC vs Columbus Crew Prediction

Major League Soccer · Sun 10 May 2026
USA flag USA : Major League Soccer
New York City FCDDWDW
21:30
⏳ Result pending · Sun 10 May
Columbus CrewDWWWW
Kick-offSun 10 May, 21:30
Our tip2 @ 2.70
GoalsOver 2.5
Confidence55%

Recent form

Last 5 matches, home and away
New York City FCDDWDW
07 Nov 26ADC United1 - 0Major League Soccer
31 Oct 26HCF Montreal1 - 1Major League Soccer
28 Oct 26HAtlanta United FC2 - 1Major League Soccer
24 Oct 26AOrlando City SC2 - 2Major League Soccer
17 Oct 26HLos Angeles FC1 - 1Major League Soccer
Columbus CrewDWWWW
07 Nov 26AChicago Fire4 - 3Major League Soccer
31 Oct 26HDC United3 - 0Major League Soccer
29 Oct 26AFC Dallas2 - 0Major League Soccer
24 Oct 26HToronto FC4 - 2Major League Soccer
22 Oct 26HSt. Louis City0 - 0US Open Cup

Head to head

Full head to head: New York City FC vs Columbus Crew →

Our prediction

Columbus Crew to win

@ 2.70
Double chance
12  •  New York City FC or Columbus Crew
@ 1.22
Both teams to score
Yes – both teams score
@ 1.57
Confidence
55%

Our record

Our tips on New York City FClast 20 tipped matches
7/2035%
Our tips on Columbus Crewlast 20 tipped matches
12/2060%
Our tips in Major League Soccerlast 30 days
34/6057%

Correct 1X2 tips (home win, draw or away win), checked against the final score.

Who will win?

Voting closed at kick-off.

Goals outlook

Over/Under 2.5
Over 2.5
Confidence
85%
Over 2.5: 61%Under 2.5: 39%
Expected goals
1.19New York City FC
3.14Total
1.95Columbus Crew

Possible correct scores

1 – 1 Draw 10% @ 6.00
2 – 1 New York City FC win 8% @ 7.50
1 – 2 Columbus Crew win 8% @ 8.00 Our pick
1 – 0 New York City FC win 7% @ 8.50
0 – 1 Columbus Crew win 7% @ 9.00

Exact scores are long shots – even the likeliest score usually comes in only 1 time in 8–10. 18+.

Win probability

New York City FC35%
Draw17%
Columbus Crew48%

Odds (1X2)

12.40
X3.55
22.70

New York City FC vs Columbus Crew preview

New York City FC host Columbus Crew in the Major League Soccer (USA) on Sunday 10 May 2026 at 21:30 Nigerian time. Here is our prediction, the odds, both teams' recent form and their head-to-head record.

Our model gives New York City FC a 35% chance of winning, the draw 17% and Columbus Crew 48%. That makes our pick Columbus Crew to win with 55% confidence at odds of 2.70. For a safer option, the double chance 12 (New York City FC or Columbus Crew) covers two of the three results at odds of 1.22.

Goals: we expect about 3.1 goals (1.2 for New York City FC, 2.0 for Columbus Crew). The chance of three or more goals is 61%, so our goals pick is Over 2.5 (85% confidence).

Form and head to head

New York City FC have 2 wins, 3 draws and 0 defeats in their last 5 matches (D-D-W-D-W), scoring 7 and conceding 5. Columbus Crew have 4 wins, 1 draw and 0 defeats in their last 5 matches (D-W-W-W-W), scoring 13 and conceding 5. In the table, New York City FC are 11th with 42 points and Columbus Crew are 7th with 47 points.

Frequently asked questions

Who will win New York City FC vs Columbus Crew?

Our prediction is Columbus Crew to win (55% confidence) at odds of 2.70. Win chances: New York City FC 35%, draw 17%, Columbus Crew 48%.

Will there be over 2.5 goals in New York City FC vs Columbus Crew?

We expect about 3.1 goals. Our pick is Over 2.5 with 85% confidence (chance of 3+ goals: 61%).

What time is New York City FC vs Columbus Crew?

New York City FC vs Columbus Crew (Major League Soccer) kicks off on Sunday 10 May 2026 at 21:30 Nigerian time (WAT).

What is a safe bet for New York City FC vs Columbus Crew?

The double chance 12 (New York City FC or Columbus Crew) covers two outcomes at odds of 1.22. No bet is risk-free – stake only what you can afford. 18+.

Predictions are estimates from our model, not guarantees. 18+ only – bet responsibly. More: today's predictions · Bet Slip Builder · booking codes.

Major League Soccer table

New York City FC11th42 pts
Columbus Crew7th47 pts
#TeamPWDLGDPts
1 Nashville SC 342383 4677
2 Inter Miami 3416126 2160
3 New England Revolution 3418412 858
4 Chicago Fire 3416711 1055
5 Charlotte 3415910 1554
6 Philadelphia Union 3414812 1450
7 Columbus Crew 3414515 747
8 Orlando City SC 3413714 -1546
9 FC Cincinnati 34121012 -846
10 New York Red Bulls 3412616 -1442
11 New York City FC 34101212 442
12 Toronto FC 3491213 -1539
13 Atlanta United FC 349619 -1733
14 DC United 3471215 -2233
15 CF Montreal 346820 -3226